decided to try out tolly's with a couple of friends since our usual place closed early, and i honestly wish i stayed home. we came in around 11 which I figured wasn't a horrible time to try and order food as well as drinks, but I was so horribly mistaken. I ordered a white russian and a mushroom swiss burger. i didn't think the fact that "mushroom" isn't plural on the menu meant i would quite literally only get one mushroom on my burger. it was basically inedible from how unseasoned the patty was and it was impressive how the cheese didn't taste like anything. aside from the food, my drink wasn't even made properly. it was basically a milkshake because it was very apparent that there was no vodka in it. just coffee liquor and heavy cream. on top of that, the prices were ridiculous. the burger with tots was already around $14 and the drink was no less than 6-7 dollars for a drink with almost no alcohol in it.
i do appreciate how the place is lgbtq+ friendly and has extensive amount of decor. our server was also very friendly and accommodating, but that's the only amount of good i got for my first time.
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 3