Update 9/8/23 - My mom surprised me with an almond raspberry cake for my birthday. Absolutely delicious! Thank you for another fabulous cake!
I’ve bought two strawberry custard cakes from Even Batter in the past and they both were outstanding. This past weekend we had an assortment of cupcakes - Each and every one has been delicious! They are super nice and easy to work with. I highly recommend!
So, I’m giving 4 stars based upon having a special order cake, enjoying a cupcake, and enjoying the cheesecake cupcakes. I ordered a specialty TARDIS cake for my mother’s birthday as she is a huge Doctor WHO fan. It looked spot on like what I’d asked for, and in buttercream no less (fondant is cute, but practically inedible because it’s just frankly chewy and not too tasty). There were just a few details added that were in fondant. The icing was delicious; my experience with dark colored icings is they are usually quite bitter and unpleasant, but this was sweet and delightful. The cupcakes are equally as lovely. The only reason I’m holding that 5th star is the cheesecake cupcakes were a bit more cheese consistency than cake. While they were divinely delicious, they require a spoon or fork, and plate to be eaten. I would definitely still buy them again (particularly the raspberry or the salted caramel), but I’ll be better prepared when serving them.
I ordered a cake for my daughters baby shower. Not only was it delicious it was beautiful!! Exactly how I ordered it. They are creative and super nice to work with.
Best cake ever!!! I will be returning.
BEST custom bakery around! Ordered custom cake for 50th birthday! It was gorgeous and this son/mother team actually improved on the design I sent them! It tasted great (two flavors) and the family enjoyed cake for two days after the party! Will definitely use Even Batter for all my celebrations!
Even Batter made our wedding cake and cupcakes for our reception. The wedding cake was beautiful and the cupcakes were delicious!! All our guests kept asking where they were from because they were so delicious!
